(editor's
note: The RV Builder's Hotline is again being published. To
subscribe, click the link above. No messge is necessary.)
So you want to build an RV airplane? by
Bob Collins
Those
of us who are building (or flying an RV), especially those of
us who have been building for a long time, tend to forget that
there are probably more new RV builders coming onto the scene
every year than any year previous. Sometimes we think the entire
RV universe is focused on that component we're focused
on, and that if a question has been asked before, and we
know it, then everyone else knows it too.
But every
week, several folks signing up for the RV Builders Group on
Yahoo report they're either considering or just starting their
projects, and when I chat with them, I realize that everybody
needs a primer (not the paint kind) on things. This is for those
of you who have already decided to
build an RV.
Let's assume
that you've already made the decision about whether to buy a
quick
build or slow build kit. (By the way, vaunted RV builder
Sam Buchanan
had a very insightful point on a discussion going
on this week on the RV List. If you order a quick build
kit, it only gives you a leg up on building the airframe. Once
that's completed, you and the slow builders now take the same
route the rest of the way) . Let's
also assume you have the unqualified support of your
spouse and family. And let's assume you've researched the
general guidelines surrounding being
a homebuilder. Oh, and there's that
money thing.
That leaves
us at just a few points: where can I get help, how much space
do I need and what do I need to buy? OK, maybe there's a few
more than that, but for the purposes of getting you started
on the right track, let's concentrate on just those three this
week.
WHERE DO I GET
HELP?
Years ago,
before there was much of an Internet and such a thing as pre-punched
kits, people used to build RVs by looking at the plans, maybe
stopping by an
EAA chapter and then they, well, did it. Heck, before that,
they were building straight from plans! We call these people
"real builders." Now, you have almost instantaneous access
to almost any solution to almost any problem, and with more
than 4,000 RVs flying and thousands more under construction,
it'll be hard to feel alone as you build; unless, of course,
you want to.
I won't
bother going into the value of the
EAA and the local chapters, for it's unlikely you've gotten
this far without hearing of them. And there's
also magazines. These are some of my recommendations.
First, Kitplanes is rapidly becoming an indispensable
resource for the homebuilder, if only to provide something to
read to provide inspiration. Sport Aviation
from EAA also falls into this category. Columnist Lauran Paine
Jr., by the way, is an RV-8 builder and pilot. Other magazines
provide at least some direction for the homebuilder - or at
least the pilot - and these include Plane & Pilot. I also enjoy Pilot
Getaways because it provides me with "builder motivation."
Motivation?
Why? It's a plane. It's cool. It looks like fun. I'm motivated
and ready to go. Yeah, OK, me too. But there are going to be
times when motivation sags a little bit. Think of your project
from the very moment you open the box as a series of small projects.
Read about others' first flights, go to the airport and get
a ride in an RV periodically as you build. Watch
videos. You
Tube is your friend.
One reference
book you simply must order is
FAA AC43.13. It is, basically, the bible of aircraft construction
and it will tell you what the acceptable practices are for just
about anything you'll be doing on the plane. As you go along
in the project, you'll find yourself dog-ea ring more and more
portions of the manual. In addition, again as you get farther
along, you'll probably be buying one or more of the books by
the late Tony
Bingelis, published by the EAA on firewall forward and engines
etc.
But perhaps
the biggest revolution in homebuilding has come as the result
of the Internet. In fact, many builders make sure there's room
for a laptop in their work area, both for asking questions and
looking at other builders' sites. The oldest of these support
groups is probably the RV
List, operated by Matt Dralle. It also the most controversial, given to flame wars and off-topic brouhahas, the atmosphere for inspired the alternatives that have now become more useful for pure RV information and collegiality. On the other hand, if you're into AM talk radio, you'll find like-minded souls on the RV List.
For Web sites,
Doug Reeves' Van's
Air Force site is probably the king of the hill, mostly
as a result of the forums section where dozens and dozens of
posts are made each hour. Doug also monitors the world of RV
news and usually posts an update on his front page every evening.
There's so much material on this site, that's it's almost impossible
to find it all without a search engine. The solution, of course,
is Google, using Van's Air
Force as one of the key phrases. The forum section does have
a search function. The advertisements are plentiful, but the
depth of material is astounding. Don't miss the
set of articles, some of which are already linked in this
article.
There's
also the RV Builders Group on Yahoo, which
I took on after Doug - who started his enterprise, actually,
with a Yahoogroup - decided to shut down the RV-7 group (and
some other model-specific Yahoogroups) and consolidated them
at VAF as the forum software proved its mettle. It is not as
busy as either of the other two sites, but
the Yahoo RSS feed is superior and there's very little non-RV
conversation taking place there. And Rivetbangers, is
a growing and comprehensive site whose main focus is the forums.
You also
may be interested in various regional builder groups online
and offline. In Southern California, for example, the So-Cal group
on Yahoo is very active. In the Ohio Valley area, the same
can be said for the Ohio Valley
RVators group on Yahoo. In the U.K, the rvsqn
site on Yahoo is among the most active. In Ontario, Canada
- a hotbed of RV activity-you'll find the Ontario
RVAtors group, and I enjoy the Tennessee
Valley RV Builders Group.
Builders
groups are important for you to discover - and soon - because
you'll find one of the best parts about building an RV isn't
just the airplane, it's the people you meet while building the
airplane. In my neck of the woods, for example, we have the
Minnesota
Wing of Van's Air Force, which has a meeting every quarter.
These groups are invaluable. Now, Van's has a list of RV related Web sites
and groups, but it's not very comprehensive because Tom Greene,
the president of Van's, has dictated that sites with ads cannot
be listed (except for the Van's Air Force site). That's fine,
but a lot of the best sites that don't want to ask for contributions,
use Google ads, for example, to defray their expenses for keeping
up the fine work. They don't get listed and you don't find out
about them. Plus many of the links don't work. VAF has a links page, but it's heavily
advertiser related, and it leaves the builder sites to - you
guessed it - Van's. See the problem?
Fortunately,
many of the primary builder sites that are out there have extensive
links pages. I can't possibly list them all, but I'll give you
some of my personal favorites and if you follow them all and
take enough time exploring (hey, what else are you going to
do while waiting for those boxes from Oregon to show up?), you'll
eventually start running into the same ones. Aside from those
already mentioned, I give a nod to the RV
Builder's Hotline - of course I do, I run it - which is
a Web site archive for a weekly, free newsletter that takes
the best threads of the support groups and the news in the RV
world and aggregates it into a single spot. For specific models, Dan Checkoway's RV-7 site has become the
de facto instruction manual. But before Dan, there was - and,
of course, still is - Sam Buchanan's
RV Aircraft
Journal, which documents Sam's RV-6. Since the RV-10 has
come along, Tim Olson has put together a fabulous site called
myrv10.com.. RV-9 fans will find Smitty's
RV-9A particularly useful. It also has a very good links
page, even though I don't think the Hotline is on it. Hey, do
something about that, will ya, Smitty? Kevin Horton's RV-8 site "One rivet at
a time" is extremely comprehensive and functional. Again, great
links and Kevin's RSS feed is one I keep an eye on.
I also would suggest
- off the top of my head - Dave Parsons' dualrudder.com
site and Mickey Coggins'
RV-8 site as well as Randy
Lervold's RV-8 site. Randy, by the way, runs EAA
Chapter 105, which used to be the "home wing" of Van's Air
Force. They put out a sensational newsletter.
Other non-model-specific
Web sites I find very helpful are rvuk.co.uk and a new one in South
Africa -- RV
Club SA, under the direction of RV builder Rudi Grayling.
Believe me, those
are just some of the many Web sites that are out there and I
apologize to those of you (especially those of you who have
added RV Builder's Hotline to your links pages!) that I didn't
mention. Shoot, maybe I should have a links page afterall.
HOW MUCH SPACE
DO I NEED?
Van's instruction
section - I think it was Section 5 - is right when it says you
can never have too much space. I've heard of RVs being built
- but I don't know how - in big-city apartments. I also, of
course, see plenty of them going up in hangars. Me? I'm building
in a typical two-car garage in the suburbs of St. Paul, Minnesota.
It's just your typical suburban home; nothing fancy and certainly
nothing with an abundance of space. I chose the garage because,
well, I didn't want to pay for a hangar and, besides, you can
build a lot faster the closer the project is to where you live.
So
far - I'm on the finishing kit - I've been able to build my
airplane in the garage and still get my wife's car in the garage
in the winter, which is the most important thing in my house.
I haven't hung the engine yet (because I haven't bought one
yet) and I don't see any way of doing it in the garage so at
some point - probably soon - I'll have to move it to the airport.
My wings, once they were built, are down in the "family room,"
or at least what use to be the family room in the finished basement.
It helps if you have a large window that you can remove the
panes and get the wings in. Or a walk-out
door. My garage is 18 x 21 but once you add in the lawnmower,
air compressor, work bench, golf clubs, snowblower, baseball
equipment, old plastic pots etc., well, let's just say it's a lot smaller.
Use of space
is simply a matter of use
of creativity. After you read this article, get out there
and be creative!
The first thing you'll
need to do - unless you're loaded with money (I hear some RV
builders are, actually) and have one of those neat set-ups that
I've seen in the exhibit halls at AirVenture - is a solid workbench.
Nothing fancy is needed and the prevailing wisdom is the plans
that Chapter 1000 have
made available (drawings)
are more than adequate.
Van's points
out, by the way, that you'll need as much workspace regardless
of whether you're building a slow-build or a quick-build kit.
WHAT DO I NEED
TO BUY?
We'll get to tools
in just a second, but the first thing you need to buy is a weekend
at a SportAir workshop. The
EAA runs these and any of them are valuable, but in particular
the RV Assembly
class is really a must. A few years ago at Oshkosh, one EAA
volunteer running a sheet metal workshop said "if the first
time you work with sheet metal is when you start working on
the empennage, you'll be buying a second empennage." He was
right. The workshop will show you a number of techniques you'll
need to master and send you home with the
confidence to say "I can do this." RVers such as Ken Scott
of Van's and Dan Checkoway teach or have taught these classes.
Yes, they're a little pricey, but that's something you probably
need to get used to as well.
Even if your last
name is Vila, you'll be buying tools
during the first few years of your airplane project; lots of
tools. In fact, you may be spending more
money on tools during the first year than you will on airplane
parts. I've always said $2,000 is probably a bit on the conservative
side of things.
Perhaps
the biggest expense at first will be the most important - an
air compressor. You can't build an airplane without an air compressor
to power the tools. Don't go cheap here. And don't go with an
oilless compressor unless you really don't like your neighbors
and unless you've always wanted to learn how to say "fasten
your seatbelts" in American Sign Language.
Be careful
when talking to people about air compressors. People really
love their air compressors and will tell you that the kind they
own is the kind you've just got to have to keep from
falling out of the sky. Oh, by the way, I own a Husky Pro, 135
max psi, 26 gallon, 5 hp air compressor (Home Depot, about $400 I think). It's
more than adequate for the task, although it will cycle fairly
quickly when using die grinders and doing a lot of drilling.
I don't think I'd use it for painting (but I probably won't
paint my own anyway), so you might even want to go bigger.
There's
plenty of threads on the various boards about air compressors.
One going on this week at Van's Air Force, for example,
looks at the suggested
minimum specs. That brings up another aspect of tools. Don't
think in terms of minimum. You can get buy with that philosophy.
But probably not for long. Trust me,
I tried.
I read the
Section 5 (or maybe it was 4) of Van's manual - the one that
talks about tools etc. - and I got the impression that maybe
I could save a few bucks by not ordering the way-too-expensive
Scotchbrite wheels. Wrong. I lasted until the second part of
the empennage, and then went and bought a bench grinder and
the medium 3M wheel. The wheel itself is up to around $50 but
it's invaluable for deburring and polishing. I actually have
two on the same bench grinder. The medium is one side,
the fine is on the other. I use the latter after using the former.
And the "fine" Scotchbrite is good for polishing up scratches
etc.
A smaller
die grinder is also recommended on the tail kit, although it's
use is probably limited to using the small Scotchbrites to do
the
inside lightening holes of various parts on the empennage.
You'll use it a bit more later in the
kit, so it's a nice to have thing.
An air drill
is also highly recommended. You can use an electric drill or
a cordless, but in many cases the drill bits don't turn fast
enough and you'll get elongated holes. I use a 2,600 rpm Sioux
air drill.
After you
drill a hole, you'll need to deburr it to prevent cracking and
stress points (you can read about this in the early part of
the Van's manual. I'm trying not to be repetitive), so a hand
deburrer and a deburring bit will
need to be ordered. There have been some advances in recent
years. Some people swear by the Burraway
tool, which apparently does both sides of the hole at once.
I can't recommend it - or not recommend it - since I don't own
one, however.
The ribs
for the various components of an RV are stamped out of sheet
metal. The stamping process tends to bend them a bit so they
won't lie quite flat. Unfortunately,s ince the holes are prepunched,
that means the holes probably won't line up with the skins either.
So you have to do two things. First, "flute" the ribs
(put little creases in them) and for that you'll need a pair
of "fluting pliers." They run $15-$20. You'll find
the biggest need for these when you get to the wings and build
your leading edge and fuel tanks, but you'll find some minor
fluting is needed before then.
You'll also need
to bend the flanges of the ribs just a bit. You could do this
with just your fingers and brute strength, but hand seamers
are recommended. Again, anywhere between $15 and $20.
OK, we've
got the drilling, straightening and deburring out of the way,
we're not talking about priming here, so what's left. Ah, yes,
riveting. If you've never used a riveting gun before, you may
be wary of using a riveting gun and bucking bar. Eventually
you'll get used to it after you make enough mistakes. This is
the time to make those mistakes. You'll first be faced with
buying a 2X or 3X gun and this is another area where you can get confused in a hurry by listening
to too many people. Read this item in an RV builders group newsletter, then pick
one. Don't think too much about it.
Just pick one. You'll learn to use it regardless of what kind
you choose. And, by the way, I'm not getting into warnings about
using these drill bits or not using air hammers etc., because
presumably by now you've seen all those
elsewhere or, if not, you will)
There are two basic
kinds of rivets. Flush head rivets are exactly what they say
and go on the outside surfaces of the plane (and elsewhere)
where you want smoothness and good air flow (or, for other parts
of the plane, clearance), and universal head rivets. Both get
bucked the same way, you put a rivet "set" in a gun, put it
on the "manufactured end" and put a bucking bar on the other
end (the "shop head") and "buck." So you'll need rivet "sets". These are simply the things that go
in the rivet gun. Get a few, including an "offset' rivet set
which allegedly helps you get into tight spaces (see an example) to rivet. You'll
mostly use this on the wings and if you're like me, won't find
it particularly helpful. But buy it anyway because maybe it's
just me.
Be sure
to by a swivel head universal rivet set. I recommend it over
the "mushroom" kind. Cleaveland Tools, a few years
ago, carried this next to the picture of thing, "recommended
by many, but not by us." They couldn't be more wrong. It'll
save a lot of dings. Maybe they were concerned about poor riveting
technique, but this item is absolutely indispensable to me.
(Here's a Word
document on riveting technique, by the way)
There are,
especially with the empennage, lots of areas where you can "squeeze"
rivets by hand. Initially, anyway, this is the method you'll
feel more comfortable with. So you'll need a "squeezer," probably.
Funny. This is another area that spurs
debate. Hand squeezer vs. pneumatic squeezer. Like many other
areas, the decision on this often comes down to "do I want to
spend money?" vs. "do I want to spend more money?".
Hand squeezers run over $100. Pneumatic squeezers can run $500
or $600 (and you'll need to buy squeezer rivet "sets" for these
too). Folks swear by the pneumatic, but like other tools, you
can build a plane without one if you want.
For hand squeezers,
I use a Tatco squeezer only because when I was in the position
you may now find yourself in, I camped next to some Ontario
RVers at Oshkosh and a man who said he's built four RVs recommended
Tatco. So I bought a Tatco. They were sold by Cleaveland Tools
(and maybe still are), although after I'd already bought the
Tatco, Cleaveland came out with its Main Squeeze, which now
appears to be the most favored hand squeezer.
The squeezer - and
the pneumatic squeezer too - have another job. Dimpling.
You know by now, hopefully, that dimpling makes the
indentation in aircraft skin, into which the flush head
rivet goes. Using dimple dies in a squeezer, makes the dimples.
You'll need a set of #40 dimple dies and this will be the ones
you use most often on the plane. A #30 set will also be used
and, if you want to spend the money now, a
#8 and #10 dimple will be required for the screws on
the wing kit.
 |
| Dimpling
skins with a C-frame tool |
For those
areas where you can't reach with a squeezer to dimple, a C-frame
tool is the answer. It's just a contraption that allows you
to insert the same dies you'd use in a hand squeezer and then
use it to reach holes that need dimpling, usually on skins.
For this there is a way-too-expensive (in my opinion) option
of the c-frame (actually, it's not much of an option, you'll
have to buy one). Both Cleaveland and Avery sell these, but
there's a new one that came on the market a few years ago that
apparently is worth the money. The DRDT-2's convenience
and effectiveness appears to be unquestioned. Like a pneumatic
squeezer, you'll just have to decide for yourself. But you'll
be spending anywhere between $120 and almost $400 here. See?
It doesn't take long to add up. Sorry.
Clecos are
one of those things you can't have enough of. If you buy one
of those "starter" kits, you'll get a handful of clecos. Advertising
that the starter sets give you all the things you need is borderline
fraudulent. A handful of clecos will be mostly useless. They're
expensive, about 30-35 cents apiece but, like I said, you might
as well get used to it. I bought 100 clecos to start with -
buy mostly the 3/16 (#40 hole - silver) ones and maybe 50-100
of the copper colored (1/8", #30 hole) ones and you'll be fine
to start. Then, for the next year or so, whenever you make an
order with a tool supplier, order another bag (usually 25).
When you get to the wings, you'll need LOTS of clecos. I ended
up with about two plastic-milk-jugs full of the silver. You
can always sell 'em when you're done. Buy cleco pliers too.
Get two. You'll lose one.
The Van's
list contains a host of other hand tools you'll need. These
include aircraft snips (for cutting sheet metal), which you
won't use that often, a microstop countersink cage and bit (order one for a #30
and a #40 to start), Vixen files, and, of course drill bits
(#40 and #30 you'll use a lot. A #10 and a #12 and a #19 will
also be needed fairly soon. Buy regular sizes from aircraft
tool suppliers only, also buy a couple of 6" and 12"
#30 and #40 bits). You won't really need a rivet cutter
as indicated, however.
One word
about the microstop countersink cage and bit. Sounds precise,
doesn't it. Be careful! It's not. This is a tool you'll need
to practice on and this is a good time to do it. Buy a cage
with ball bearing construction. Cheap stuff doesn't work here.
The countersink, by the way, replaces the "dimple."
In some cases, what's being "dimpled" is too thick
to be "indented"...so we countersink and actually
remove metal in the shape of the rivet head instead. There's
more about that in the early sections of Van's manual (you ordered
preview plans, right?)
A band saw
is helpful, but not necessary in the empennage kit if you're
looking to save now and spend later. You can make what few parts
you need to make with a hacksaw and file if you don't particularly
mind using a hacksaw and file. But a bandsaw zips up the work
a bit at the emp stage, and I think it's pretty much a needed
tool at the wing stage when you're making a few doubler plates.
I bought
a Harbor
Freight Tools band saw and if you buy this model, especially
if you live in the northern climates, buy a bunch of replacement
blades because in the winter they snap like crazy. If you really
like this particular model, stop by the garage and take mine
home. My dad passed away in 2004 and I'm just now getting around
to cleaning
out his workshop and he had a really nice Delta bandsaw.
It was a good reminder to buy quality stuff.
Bench press
drill. Yeah, get one.
As I've
indicated, there are other tools that you will find quite handy.
And these include, by the way, a little gizmo to help you drill
out bad rivets. This is another one of those areas where you
can just eyeball it with a regular drill and drill bit but this
will help you drill right in the center of the manufactured
head, so that you can snap it off and remove a bad rivet. And,
trust me, you will have bad rivets. On the other hand,
you will have to quickly learn when to drill out a rivet and
when not to because you can quickly make a bad situation worse,
even with this tool. Me? I don't drill out 1/8 rivets in doubler
plates. I just don't. Too much of a chance of making a real
mess.
There are plenty
of areas to get RV-related information, but on the tools front,
consider broadening your kitplane horizon. I say this because
Zenith Aircraft has a lot of good advice on sheet metal tools
and their use. When you take a break from your tool ordering,
leaf through their site
for some very good articles.
With a few exceptions,
I haven't put a bunch of links to tool sellers. Any of those
Web sites listed above will have them. I will put in a plug,
however, for Avery
Tools and Cleaveland
Tools. Both of these folks are RV builders and both are
the type that will come to the phone if you have questions,
or at least answer an e-mail. You'll also see them at RV gatherings,
often donating door prizes and such. You won't see that with
some of the other folks, no matter how good they are. Personally,
I like personal service and
high quality and given all the money I'll end up having to earn
and spend on the project, I don't really mind spending a few
extra dollars to get it.
Incidentally,
fall -- specifically September - is
a great time to buy tools. Many of the RV tool suppliers gear
up for the air show season, which ends around August. By September,
they're looking to reduce inventory and you can usually save
a lot of money. So look around. If you can get to Oshkosh during
AirVenture - or any other major fly-in - you can usually get
some "deals." But be careful! There's
a lot of cheap tools out there and a lot of suppliers
who sell cheap tools. Ask for recommendations. And then avoid
them! It's not worth the savings.
Others strongly recommend
E-Bay and while I respect their opinion, many of the experts
I've seen speak and talk say be very careful when buying
tools on E-Bay.
Remember,
this may be a boxload of parts now.
But in a few years, it's going to be carrying you and, perhaps,
your loved one. Is this really where you want to cut
corners?
And finally,
tools I heartily recommend. Protection. Ear protection. Eye
protection. Lung protection. This isn't the area to go cheap
by a long shot. Get up to Home Depot or Lowe's or Sears or whever
and pick up a good 3M organic respirator, and good hearing protection.
Buy about a half dozen safety glasses. You'll be leaving them
all over the place and losing them anyway.
WHAT
ELSE?
You'll need
to plan for a building log to document your progress and, basically,
prove to the DAR that you built the thing. There's lots of threads
on bulletin boards out there about whether you need pictures
or whether the pictures need to include you in a few of them.
Forget that. Why wouldn't you want a picture of you
building something? This is you we're talking about here! Building
a plane! Trust me, when all is said and done, you'll want a
scrapbook of some sort about the greatest construction project
you ever undertook in your life. Imagine that getting handed
down to the next generation!
There are
a few ways to go here. Kitlog
Pro not only keeps track of your progress and creates an
album (with pictures) for you, it also allows you to organize
your expenses and contact records, and also includes some PDFs
of documents you're going to need. It's a little pricey, in
fact it's gone up about 25% since I bought it, but I'm happy
with it, for what that's worth.
There is
also ExperCraft
if you want to maintain an online log. This is a fascinating
product developed by Rob Riggen of Vermont. Rob also developed
the tools that allow the RV Builder's Hotline to be produced
and distributed each week. The cool part about this is it not
only creates a log, it also creates a Web site for you. And
if you've added up the numbers in this article so far, you'll
love this part: it's free.
There's
no way in an article, you learn everything about planning for
the actual start of construction of your project. That's what
the reference links are for. This is an exciting time for you
and, possibly, there's a bit of apprehension mixed in. Rest
assured there's an RV community waiting to help. Just remember:
pass it on!
FOR MORE INFORMATION
I've set up
a small Amazon
store with some recommended books etc., for the purposes of
this article. Any purchase made their helps support the newsletter.
But don't feel compelled. Still, there's some books there that
I highly recommend.
See also:
Brian Meyette's Web page on RV Tools